Illusions of is-ought gaps
Hume's Guillotine proposes that there is a gap between what can be described in our world as "what is" and what can be prescribed as what "ought to be", the gap is meant to symbolize a causal disconnection. However, the three points below show a causal connection, making the gap an illusion. 1. It's impossible to have any notion of what ought to be without a description of what is. The prescription "people ought not steal" requires, for its own existence, a description of what it means to steal: to own something and for someone to take without consent and/or payment. This means that moral prescriptions don't exist in a moral realm separated by the is-ought gap; instead they exist as a consequence from descriptive reality where the is-ought gap is simply one of ignorance. Analogous to the fossil record gap that causes some skeptics to doubt the link between humans and apes. 2. The conclusion of how the world ought to be is simply a description ...